top of page
Search

The Empty Chair: Why Doesn't Anyone Want to Be the Boss?

11 minutes ago
3 min read

Picture a conference room with a long table. Around it are the people responsible for making decisions, solving problems, and leading the organization forward.

And then there's an empty chair.


For years, that chair represented opportunity. A promotion. A bigger title. More responsibility. The chance to move up the corporate ladder.


We assumed someone would want to sit in it. But what happens when no one does?


When the Next Generation Says, "No Thanks"

A recent SHRM article, Unbossing Challenges the Traditional Career Ladder, highlights a growing trend called "unbossing." Employees, particularly younger workers, are questioning whether stepping into management is worth the additional stress, responsibility, and potential impact on their personal lives.


It's an interesting shift, particularly for those of us who have spent our careers helping organizations identify and develop their next generation of leaders.


I've worked in HR and talent development for more than 20 years, and one thing I've learned is that identifying leadership potential and developing someone's desire to lead are two very different things.


We spend considerable time asking, "Who's ready for the next opportunity?" But perhaps we should be asking another question.


"Have we created leadership opportunities that people actually want?"

What Do Employees See When They Look at Their Leaders?

Think about the managers in your organization.


Are they energized by their work? Do they have time to coach, develop, and connect with their teams? Are they supported when making difficult decisions?


Or are they constantly juggling competing priorities, attending back-to-back meetings, addressing performance issues, and trying to meet expectations with limited resources?

Employees notice these things.


They're watching how leaders spend their time, handle pressure, and balance their professional and personal lives. And they're asking themselves a very reasonable question.

"Do I really want that job?"


This doesn't necessarily mean they lack ambition or aren't interested in growing. They may simply have a different definition of success.


Preparing People Is Only Half the Equation

As an HR and leadership development consultant, I believe strongly in building leadership pipelines. Organizations need to identify talent, provide development opportunities, and prepare people for future responsibilities.


But we also need to look at what happens after someone accepts that promotion.

Consider this finding from SHRM's research on developing managers: Only 30% of organizations have a formal onboarding process for employees promoted internally into management.


Think about that.


We recognize someone's potential, give them a new title and additional responsibilities, and too often expect them to figure out the rest.


Then we wonder why others are hesitant to follow.

Leadership development can't begin and end with a promotion. It requires ongoing coaching, meaningful feedback, opportunities to practice, and organizational support. And sometimes it requires us to rethink the job itself.

Making the Chair Worth Sitting In

If we want to develop future leaders, I believe we need to do three things differently.


1. Make leadership visible for the right reasons. Employees need to see leaders who are making a difference, developing others, and finding meaning in their work, not just managing stress and putting out fires.


2. Prepare people before they take the seat. Give employees opportunities to lead projects, make decisions, coach others, and develop confidence before they're responsible for an entire team.


3. Ask what makes the opportunity worthwhile. Have honest conversations about career aspirations. Understand what motivates employees, what concerns them, and what support they would need to succeed. And recognize that not every talented employee wants or needs to become a manager.


Take Another Look at That Empty Chair

An empty leadership chair should prompt more than a conversation about succession planning.


It should prompt us to examine the leadership experience we're creating.


Are we giving managers the tools, resources, authority, and support they need? Are we demonstrating that leading others can be both meaningful and rewarding?


Or are we asking people to take on more responsibility without giving them what they need to be successful?


As leaders and HR professionals, we have an opportunity to change that narrative.

Because the goal isn't simply to convince someone to fill the next empty chair.


It's to create a leadership experience that makes the right people want to pull up a chair. And perhaps that's where the next generation of leadership development needs to begin.


 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page